Wrong battery percentage being reported after battery change

Question:
Any ideas on how to fix so that the OS reports the correct battery percentage?

Context:

• I changed the battery on my own.
• The computer charges fine up to what is being reported by the OS as 100%.
• After disconnecting the power cable the OS will soon report the battery percentage to be 1%.
• I am able to run the computer fine on 1% for an hour or so.
• Battery condition is reported as "normal" by the OS.

Symptom:

Thank you for your answer.

I just tried resetting SMC but it didn't help.

CoconutBattery when power cable is disconnected:

CoconutBattery when the power cable was just connected:

CoconutBattery when the power cable has been connected for 5 minutes: