MacBook turns off randomly during high CPU load after battery replace

Question

MacBook Pro 16" 2019

于2019年11月发售的MacBook Pro 16''的维修指南和拆解信息。型号A2141，EMC 3347。

211 个问题查看全部

Brian Cardarella @briancardarella

声誉积分: 1

1

发帖于: 2023年4月21日

更多选项

MacBook turns off randomly during high CPU load after battery replace

I followed the battery replacement instructions and while plugged into power there are no issues. Laptop continues to run just fine when I unplug the power. However, if there is something that causes the fans to really kick into gear while running on battery alone the Macbook will randomly turn off sometimes. The fan will make a loud "gasp" as it powers off. I can turn it back on but unless I plug into power it will likely turn off again during boot because this is causing the fan to run hard. How do I diagnose this?

Here is the image from CoconutBattery FWIW I wasn't seeing this issue prior to swapping the battery. Nothing else has changed other than the new iFitxit battery.

回答此问题我也有这个问题

这是一个好问题吗？

是否

得分 0

6条评论

@briancardarella - Well the good news is the battery and charger look good! So this is looking like a cooling issue.

由 Dan 完成的 2023年4月21日

how do I address that? When I had the case open I took the opportunity to completely clear out all of the debris blocking the fan ports and air-pressure sprayed the fans to expel anything in there. From what I can tell there shouldn't be any restriction on airflow

由 Brian Cardarella 完成的 2023年4月21日

@briancardarella - Time to get TG-Pro installed to see what it sees.

由 Dan 完成的 2023年4月21日

yup I got it installed, does it write to a log? Otherwise the system will shut off and I lose the historical temp data

由 Brian Cardarella 完成的 2023年4月21日

actually, in the Diagnostics section it says:

Last shutdown/sleep: Forced - Battery temperature over limit

由 Brian Cardarella 完成的 2023年4月21日

显示更多的1条评论

添加一条评论

1个答案

@briancardarella - Well the good news is the battery and charger look good! So this is looking like a cooling issue. — Dan
how do I address that? When I had the case open I took the opportunity to completely clear out all of the debris blocking the fan ports and air-pressure sprayed the fans to expel anything in there. From what I can tell there shouldn't be any restriction on airflow — Brian Cardarella
@briancardarella - Time to get TG-Pro installed to see what it sees. — Dan
yup I got it installed, does it write to a log? Otherwise the system will shut off and I lose the historical temp data — Brian Cardarella
actually, in the Diagnostics section it says:

Last shutdown/sleep: Forced - Battery temperature over limit — Brian Cardarella

Dan @danj 声誉积分: 480.2千 Self employed contract worker 35 330 971 · Answer 1 · 2023-04-21T11:15:05-07:00

最有帮助的答案

Dan @danj

声誉积分: 480.2千

Self employed contract worker

35

330

971

发帖于: 2023年4月21日

更多选项

This is a tricky one! Is the battery and/or the charging having issues or is the system overheating.

We really need to dig deeper here using two tools. The first one will allow us to see the battery and how it’s charging. Install this gem of an App CoconutBattery take a snapshot of the apps main window with the battery tab opened and the system under charge.

The second tool is this one TG-Pro it will allow you to monitor your thermals. The next time it looks like the fan is rapping up take a snapshot of the full window so we can see all of the sensors and the fans. You’ll want to play around with the windows scaling so all of the sensors can be seen in a single window otherwise you’ll need to slide the slide down to take a second snap.

Let’s see what these tell us.

这个答案有帮助吗？

是否

得分 1

添加一条评论

MacBook Pro 16" 2019

MacBook turns off randomly during high CPU load after battery replace

Update (04/21/23)

1个答案

添加你的答案