Can't get my Enter key back in.

My enter key got stuck today so I removed it using a guitar pick since that technique popped up when I googled how to remove a key. After removing some dust I tried pushing the key back in but in whatever way I try, it seems to misalign. I can hear three clicks which is also what I would have expected seeing the layout of the key. For as far as I can tell nothing broke. Anyone that knows more about a possible solution?

This is what it always ends up as, with the top right corner raised. However much I try I can't get it to fit.